If I may offer some of my own interpretation for why this is supposed to be degrading:
First of all, it makes it harder for the guards to sympathize/empathize with them, which leaves them with even less hope to get out and leads to them being treated harshly consequently, which is degrading. And the android looks play their part in that even if it wasn't something that they'd personally see as degradation. (Of course the guards would be doing their jobs anyway but it leaves no room for tricks, no room to even try to pretend to be a human, no room for one of the guards to show weakness and question what they're doing.)
Most obviously: they're being forced to do something. They didn't just go "ah wait actually let me remove my skin rq it was getting kinda uncomfortable anyway", the guards ordered them (mind you, the androids they caught that *were* deviants had been trying to *escape* getting ordered around and now they'd be ordered to do something (something that would lead to their doom too) again, except this time it's not even just "in their program" to blindly follow orders. This time they're being threatened and forced to do something against their will.) It wouldn't even matter if they wouldn't usually mind doing this, being forced to do something and remain in that state in order to not be killed is degrading.
Another aspect is that androids live with their skins being turned on. At least so far I have seen no instance of them turning it off just for the sake or "looking their true self" or anything like that, Markus did it in the tower for the sake of not being recognized as easily and yes, probably also to represent androids, but I've seen no other android do that voluntarily. Of course one could argue that that's because they need to fit into the human society, but even in their safe haven they remained with their skins turned on. Noone in Jericho seemed to think "Ah finally, I'm away from the humans and amongst other androids now, let me show my true form in peace", of course that can all just be because they're in the middle of a revolution, but saying that "they're like that", without acknowledging that they in fact do not spend most of their time "like that" doesn't really seem like a strong argument to me. I understand what you mean and I agree that under different circumstances their non-human designs wouldn't be degradation, but these circumstances make all the difference here.
Furthermore, it creates uniformity. All of the androids in the camps look exactly the same, except for male and female body shapes and the one kid, Alice, maybe their eye color and facial shape if we're looking into details up-close. But if we're just seeing the camps as they are, it's just a bunch of androids that can be lumped up and killed row by row. Even if they weren't as connected to their human looks, their identity still gets stripped away by making them look uniform. Yes, that is what they look like, but no, I do not mean their "humanity" when I'm referring to their "identity". I mean their individual looks that keep them from just becoming one big mass to the humans.
Additionally to that: Androids seem to have a certain connection to their skin. Think about North and the android that was the same model as her, they have been living their lifes with these skins and I honestly find it hard to imagine them not having built any kind of connection to the looks they'd gotten used to at all. And then having that be taken from them forcibly and having to see no mercy in the way the guards perceived them... That is degradation.
And last but not least: these camps are supposed to mimick concentration camps. So they did the equivalent of shaving their hair off and taking their autonomy, individuality and hope. Taking the last bit of similarity to humanity (of course not actual humanity in the case of the androids, but similarity, which is the only way these humans would've understood and not been able to ignore that they are alive too, by seeing their resemblance) any human could see in them and sending them to die. The most important part of this degradation is their death becoming inevitable and looming over them as the humans give them orders they can't fight against and the panic about the upcoming destruction rising as they're forced to do something themselves that'll move them one step closer to their death.
I've got no intention of arguing much further here though, just thought I'd share my thoughts on this too, hope you have a nice day
I just finished Detroit Become Human for the first time and I’m in desperate need to talk about it
Listening to "When The Walls Fell" by The Beverly Crushers for the first time and I'm lowkey getting the urge to learn parts of the Tamarian language
Sketched some characters/scenes from the play “Sherlock Holmes: Der Fall Moriarty” (The Case Moriarty) that I got to watch live today on my way home from there, Toby was a balloon dog, it was brilliant😭
Hemmer sketches :] Wanted to practice drawing Aenar/Andorians, so who would be better for that than the man with the facial features ever
May I offer you the doodles of Mr. Spock I did from memory in various of my classes today?
I can feel this guy becoming more relatable by the second, not even the more I watch the movies and just the more I think about him🧍
Hello everyone, I am having to prepare to write a speech for my literature class concerning the quality of movie adaptations of novels. So I wanted to ask: Do you guys have any adapted scenes that you found remarkable in some way? Preferably a good one, but bad examples are welcome too of course🫡
Maybe a scene from Arthur Conan Doyle‘s canon that often gets left out but you find important? Or a scene that you thought a certain adaptation absolutely nailed or really just butchered? I am specifically referring to specific scenes here and *not* to overall series’ or movies. Please do tell me about what you find remarkable in relation to the original novels, I would really appreciate any help with this as I’d started to look for examples a bit late so I only have today and tomorrow to gather them🧍♂️
This doesn’t have to concern Sherlock Holmes, it can also be about Harry Potter, etc., anything really, I just used that as an example since I plan on using Holmes as a reference/example for my thesis anyway.
Fast replies would be much appreciated, as I don’t really have any idea where to even start right now :,)
I love the sound design at the beginning of part 1, it's genuinely impressive
HELL YEAH get Sherlock to wear a hat please🥸 John please don't give up on/forget about that, I need Sherlock to wear that deerstalker lmao
ALSO!! JOHN SPEAKING GERMAN!! VERY BRIEFLY BUT STILL WOOOOO, also missing the fact that he can continue speaking in English now till Mariana reminded him is real lol but dude was kinda ready to continue👀
I wonder if there would be a possibility for the people in Detroit to make these kind of jaffa cakes for androids and instead of the orange juice stuff it's thirium, I wonder what kind of material could be used for the biscuit part of it though since androids don't seem to have a more solid version of food from what I've seen, I only know about thirium🤔
Just signed up🫡 I'm sure this is gonna be fun :]
It's the moment you've all been waiting for!! Signups are LIVE!!
It'll close on the 28th, so make sure to get your form in by then!
does anyone know any Detroit Become Human fanfictions where all the different endings of the characters meet eachother?
Cause I need to read that sort of thing
Favorite Captain?
Captain Christopher Pike 100%
(She/Her/Any pronouns) 17 | Hi! I'm gonna be sharing my fanart here :] (will also ramble every now and then)Mostly Sherlock Holmes, Star Trek and Detroit: BH at the moment, some other stuff tooMy Instagram: a_nerdynerd
158 posts